pfsense vs clearos

見到網上主要有兩大討論,
pfsense, 食resources高, 但好似比較多support
clearOS, 就可以廢D嘅機都有同樣效能, 但係好似少D support
ching們對兩隻有無咩意見, 推介邊隻多D? 因為小弟最近想起隻

另外都見過routerOS, 但係要買license, 仲有一個free嘅就係smoothwall, 相比上面兩隻有無咩優劣之處?
thanks ching.

ClearOS, 佢哋公司將 product 定位做 SME Gateway 果 d...幾合一玩法,佢哋公司都講明 firewall 唔係 first priority,事實上睇返佢哋 forum,會見到好多真係做 security 既人跳船過 pfSense,原因都係有 d 重要問題佢哋未 fix。作為 free 既用家,firewall 功能唔完善,其他野又要俾錢先得,點用?

Linux based open source 免費版似乎係 Endian 比較成熟(但佢真係較少 update)
Smoothwall 口碑幾好,但如果只打算用 community edition 都係算啦,好多有用功能要錢先用得

pfSense 係所有功能人人都用到,俾錢會有 support + tutorial 等等,係個介面無其他咁靚同 setting 可能 setting 少少複雜啦

TOP

OP, what actually do you want to achieve?

Are you going to build a DIY router+firewall or an UTM gateway?

TOP

DIY router+firewall

TOP

回覆 4# ip4368


    If you want free solution, go for pfSense.

TOP

如果唔想搞咁多野就可以用到,建議買mikrotik
因為已經裝好哂個 software,又包埋 license,即插即用


當然享受 DIY 樂趣就另計了

TOP

thanks for all comments. I am trying pfsense on a VM, 真係夠曬function,不過我想問下大概咩grade嘅硬件會有幾多nat throughput?

TOP

thanks for all comments. I am trying pfsense on a VM, 真係夠曬function,不過我想問下大概咩grade嘅硬 ...
ip4368 發表於 2015-3-28 14:23

請參考,部機8舊幾人仔
    http://www.hkepc.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=2178484

TOP

thanks for all comments. I am trying pfsense on a VM, 真係夠曬function,不過我想問下大概咩grade嘅硬 ...
ip4368 發表於 2015-3-28 14:23



    pfsense 用家
atom d2500 4G ram, dual broadcom gigalan port, performance 100MB一定無問題,估計400~700MB就到bottleneck
之前用過IPfire,幾好用,stable過pfsense, resource requirement少過pfsense好多,但係無pfsense多野玩

TOP

見到網上主要有兩大討論,
pfsense, 食resources高, 但好似比較多support
clearOS, 就可以廢D嘅機都有同樣效 ...
ip4368 發表於 2015-3-28 07:08



    新手可以玩下ipfire,比pfsense stable,無IPv6, IDS其他都有齊,但係介面差過pfsense

TOP