[測試] Spyder4/5 or i1D3?

Have been using Spyder4 (Elite) for HW calibration of my NEC PA241w
Recently acquired i1D3 and used it in my most recent calibration... Not much visual improvement over S4e

Has anyone tried both Spyder and i1 (including i1D3 and i1Pro/2) colorimeters (or spectro) on their HW calibration mons (NEC PAxxx, Eizo Coloredge etc.) and noticed significant improvement over colour accuracy?

Feedback appreciated

i would say i1d is generally more reliable then spyder, spyder known to have larger variation between devices

i1pro is more accurate for spectrum that is bright enough. so i1d may have more accurate blacks.

TOP

『 Spyder 4 校色器,對"LED螢幕"有用嗎?!』....與ColorMunki實際校色PK對照


http://m.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=164&t=2887123


我自己就早排係b&h $99買左隻 spyder5, 夾 dispcalGUI用, 除左cal勁耐之外,.感覺良好

TOP

『 Spyder 4 校色器,對"LED螢幕"有用嗎?!』....與ColorMunki實際校色PK對照


http://m.mobile01.com/topi ...
singlag 發表於 2015-9-1 21:59


文章話:
ColorMunki  適合 預算較多的 專業 使用者,於多出4倍的預算下,達到 幾乎無誤差 下的色彩標準!!

TOP

回覆 4# ivanwong


   人眼視覺真的是有極限,且因人而異,又不客觀!! 也就是為什麼要有 一標準化之工具 去幫忙囉~
依 使用者需求 不同,也就應映而生了 Spyder 4 及 ColorMunki 的不同...

Spyder 4
適合 預算不多的 非專業 使用者,在有限預算下,達到 尚可容許的誤差 下的色彩標準;
ColorMunki
則適合 預算較多的 專業 使用者,於多出4倍的預算下,達到 幾乎無誤差 下的色彩標準!!


如果睇得出測試文中幾張相的色彩有分別的話,就應該買 colormunki

TOP

回覆 4# ivanwong

回覆 5# singlag

OT folks, this thread is about S4 vs i1d3

TOP

回覆  ivanwong

回覆  singlag

OT folks, this thread is about S4 vs i1d3
anon893 發表於 2015-9-3 16:44


ColorMunki Photo無論準確度同速度都好過Spyder 4,仲有Spyder 4塊濾鏡會起蹟要自已磨翻光,而Spyder 5有無改善就唔知。

TOP

回覆 7# harryytm
Still OT

Note that ColorMunki Photo/Publish is a different animal
Do NOT get confused with ColorMunki Display

I'm discussing S4/S5 vs. i1D3 only

TOP

仲有Spyder 4塊濾鏡會起蹟要自已磨翻光. . .
harryytm 發表於 2015-9-3 05:44 PM

How?  
AFAIK Spyder enclosure is basically one-piece (?) break it open and the sensor is no more

TOP

本帖最後由 harryytm 於 2015-9-3 20:28 編輯
How?  
AFAIK Spyder enclosure is basically one-piece (?) break it open and the sensor is no more
anon893 發表於 2015-9-3 19:19

Here is an old thread talking about polishing the problem filter in Spyder 4
http://www.hkepc.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=2195898

It is easy to access that filter and I tried it before, all you need is a flat head screwdriver.

TOP