[外置硬碟] WD my passport ultra 壞左, 拆出黎點解唔同普通2.5吋

個HD插左線後, 會著燈,
知道佢係轉緊隻碟
但電腦就Run唔到, 因為想拎返D資料

諗住拆開佢, 內接底板SATA
但點知拆左出黎, 無SATA位, 個盒連HD係痴埋一舊
我唔識講

有無人知可以點救隻HD

WD 既mobile hard disk 已經變左只有USB 好耐
一般recovery software 都幫你唔到

TOP

咁姐係無得救?
以前改插底板都仲可以read到

咦家連想插sata都無



咦家read唔到隻碟
可以點呀?
有無人幫到我

via HKEPC Reader for Android

TOP

本帖最後由 anon893 於 2015-11-23 15:01 編輯

回覆 3# duckedog
You didn't do your homework to truly learn about the pitfalls of external HDD using embedded USB bridge chipset

You simply jumped on the bandwagon and chose to use it because it's convenient and cheaper

Had you used generic external HDD other than myA$$port then you could've accessed the internal HDD via direct SATA connection as you've discussed, since the embedded bridge chipset is a WD exclusive

Your only recourse would be to send your HDD to recovery labs
Expensive?  Well live with the responsibility

But before you send your HDD to the lab, perhaps you can try your luck with another USB cable first

TOP

回覆 4# anon893

其實你唔洗咁講野既
我之前用開果幾隻, 裡面都只係普通2.5吋

我第一次用WD而已, 咁跟據我過往經驗係拆出黎就用到嘛
其實你成大段文章, 有咩意思呢?

只係想叫我試下第二第Cable?
踩下人... 係會開心D?

TOP

本帖最後由 30624700 於 2015-11-24 09:08 編輯

回覆 5# duckedog

我估換過條USB Cable 未必幫到你,會著燈即係有電到,唔會咁啱淨係斷條data cable嘅
救HDD唔洗下下攞去lab 咁嫌重下話?
台灣有D user話3.0認唔到但2.0仲認到,你可以試下。又有人話棟企hdd或者反轉擺認得返
如果係PCB壞嘅話呢間shop可能有refurbished板賣,check下你塊pcb part number 先啦

http://www.hddzone.com/wd-2060771949000-pcb-p-539.html

換PCB需要係舊板拆2粒eprom 焊在新PCB, 你無能力焊嘅話可以寄塊板比seller代工 (好似話免費嘅)
Email問清楚有無貨同代工焊eprom係咪免費先落單

動手能力可以嘅話可以淘塊2手板試下,花費仲低
http://www.taobao.com/product/wd ... B7%AF%E6%9D%BF.html

板都唔淘嘅話呢到有條片可以diy 焊個SATA頭落PCB E71, E72,E73,E75 contact(注意 Capacitors C13, C18, C31 and C37要起出黎先改裝到 SATA output)
http://www.hddrecovery.ca/blog/slow-passport-data-recovery/

如果隻HDD無跌過, data又無加密嘅話換PCB有9成機會救到data,淨改SATA 8 成左右。花費不高我覺得博得過, PCB接Motor個contact係壓落去嘅,上幾粒螺絲就裝到 (需要 T6/T8星批)
最後一句:以後唔好再買,quality 真係好差, portable data放手指好D,不過都要有backup, 諗諗用cloud storage啦

TOP

回覆 5# duckedog

wd 呢樣野出曬名
下次買野可以 google 個product 名 +拆解

TOP

本帖最後由 pc1668 於 2015-11-24 16:45 編輯

回覆 1# duckedog

回覆  duckedog

wd 呢樣野出曬名
下次買野可以 google 個product 名 +拆解
marcochl 發表於 2015-11-24 15:10


I'm a fan of portable 2.5-inch hdd.  I've two Buffalo 500GB (over 4 yrs), two transcend 2TB (25A3 and 25H3) and a very ancient HGST 160GB (over 6 yrs).   We know that all or most of the newer models are using embedded USB bridge chipset (cut cost ...).   Btw, my portable HDDs are for backup purpose.   

Having googled and discussed with computer center sales people (of different shops), it seems WD my passport is one of the weakest (fragile and prone to failure) portable hdds in the market.

As per my experience, Transcend and Buffalo are far more reliable than WD.

ps.  it seems Toshiba portable hdd is also ... a bit fragile

TOP

回覆 8# pc1668
AFAIK only Western DICKgital makes ext HDDs with embedded USB bridge controller chipset, while others like HGST and Suckgate stick to traditional native SATA form

It's just sad that people are still getting MyA$$port due to price performance, and at some point someone very close to me also tried to coerce me into jumping on the bandwagon

Glad that I refused and, to this day, for price performance, would stick to (Scorpio) Blue + Transcend enclosure 25S3... works just great

TOP

本帖最後由 pc1668 於 2015-11-24 17:36 編輯
回覆  pc1668
AFAIK only Western DICKgital makes ext HDDs with embedded USB bridge controller chipse ... would stick to (Scorpio) Blue + Transcend enclosure 25S3... works just great
anon893 發表於 2015-11-24 17:29


Transcend products are pretty good.

Well,  I've a UNITEK Y-1039B enclosure which is also very stable.  
http://www.unitek-products.com/en/product_detail.php?id=256

TOP