作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-4 15:23 標題: 2.5" External HD 全部牌子都3年保?
問問
2.5" External HD 係咪
全部牌子型號都3年保?
如果有任何特別例子唔係3年保,
無論多過或少過,
可以提示一下.....
謝
作者: pc1668 時間: 2016-6-4 16:04
Other than 3-yrs of warranty, it seems we should stick with transcend and a-data as far as 'true' SATA-USB controller is concerned.
作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-5 07:40
Other than 3-yrs of warranty, it seems we should stick with transcend and a-data as far as 'true' SA ...
pc1668 發表於 2016-6-4 16:04
A-data either uses Toshiba or Seagate
inside I assume....
作者: pc1668 時間: 2016-6-5 11:03
mostly Toshiba (actually i've not seen any seagate, so far)
and my hv620 2tb is embedded with a TOSHIBA MQ01ABB200
http://www.hardware-boom.com/rev ... -2tb-2-5-hard-disk/
作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-5 12:35
mostly Toshiba (actually i've not seen any seagate, so far)
and my hv620 2tb is embedded with a T ...
pc1668 發表於 2016-6-5 11:03
no chance of HGST,
especially for 3TB...........
作者: pc1668 時間: 2016-6-5 20:30
HGST...never seen one
作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-6 23:35
mostly Toshiba (actually i've not seen any seagate, so far)
and my hv620 2tb is embedded with a T ...
pc1668 發表於 2016-6-5 11:03
Toshiba worse or Seagate worse.....?
唉........
Adata seems cheaper than Transcend,
but wish to wait for Adata 4TB............
作者: pc1668 時間: 2016-6-7 08:42
Toshiba worse or Seagate worse.....?
唉........
Adata seems cheaper than Transcend,
but wish to wait for Adata 4TB............
red_devil 發表於 2016-6-6 23:35
Toshiba worse or Seagate worse.....?
I think its a kind of 50/50
we can get an adata 3tb (2.5" portable) at less than $1K, not bad
btw, we should notice that many of the adata portable hdds do not support sleep mode (inactivity in 5~10 mins). In contrast, all or most of the transcend models do support such feature.
作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-7 09:09
Toshiba worse or Seagate worse.....?
I think its a kind of 50/50
we can get an adata 3tb (2.5" po ...
pc1668 發表於 2016-6-7 08:42
WD, Touro, Seagate external
support sleep mode?
if left never unplugged from PC or NAS,
no sleep mode over the time
could kill the HD much faster .........?
作者: pc1668 時間: 2016-6-7 09:47
本帖最後由 pc1668 於 2016-6-7 09:53 編輯
回覆 9# red_devil
"WD, Touro, Seagate external support sleep mode?"
No idea coz I don't have any of these models
"if left never unplugged from PC or NAS, no sleep mode over the time could kill the HD much faster .........?"
Can't tell. However, common sense telling me, something not designed for non-stop operation, and we stress it to run at 7x24, might lead to premature failure.
I've two transcend 2tb and one adata 2tb. All are permanently attached to (never unplugged from) NAS/Magic TV/PC. As the adata does not support sleep mode, it cannot (should not) be attached to NAS/Magic TV. Otherwise it will non-stop 'working' until the end of the world!
As my PC would power up for more than 10 hrs per day, the adata would then be non-stop 'working' for similar time. Without unplugging the hdd, there is a work-around by ejecting the usb device in Win environment. As such, it goes offline until next Win startup (not equivalent to sleep mode, just better than none!).
It seems transcend portable hdd is my real cup of tea!
作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-7 09:55
回覆 red_devil
"WD, Touro, Seagate external support sleep mode?"
No idea coz I don't have any o ...
pc1668 發表於 2016-6-7 09:47
if connected to PC all the time,
even if PC hibernate or sleep,
but HD doesn't go sleep,
then will still keep killing the HD over the time,
so "safely remove and eject HD" in windows (without unplugging the HD USB cable)
is still safer than not doing it........
can't believe such a simple sleep function is
still no supported in most external HDs,
they just want to skip this function to screw up your
HD faster so force you to buy new HD...............
作者: pc1668 時間: 2016-6-7 10:02
本帖最後由 pc1668 於 2016-6-7 10:07 編輯
if connected to PC all the time,
even if PC hibernate or sleep,
but HD doesn't go sleep,
then will still keep killing the HD over the time,
so "safely remove and eject HD" in windows (without unplugging the HD USB cable)
is still safer than not doing it........
can't believe such a simple sleep function is
still no supported in most external HDs,
they just want to skip this function to screw up your
HD faster so force you to buy new HD...............
red_devil 發表於 2016-6-7 09:55
"they just want to skip this function to screw up your HD faster so force you to buy new HD..............."
I've no idea
yes ... even the PC hibernate, the HD is still very hard working !
yes ... at least the "safely remove and eject HD" will make the hdd to go offline (sleep)
I've confirmed with HK agent 憶智 (Rubik's Express Ltd.), HV620 does NOT support sleep mode.
If the following features are deemed necessary, it seems getting a Transcend is rather safe
- sleep mode
- true SATA to USB controller
作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-7 10:18
"they just want to skip this function to screw up your HD faster so force you to buy new HD....... ...
pc1668 發表於 2016-6-7 10:02
thanks for confirmation reminder..........,,
what a waste for ADATA............
作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-8 11:05
回覆 red_devil
"WD, Touro, Seagate external support sleep mode?"
No idea coz I don't have any o ...
pc1668 發表於 2016-6-7 09:47
which HD your Transcend use inside ?
作者: pc1668 時間: 2016-6-8 12:55
25H3 2TB - WD20NPVX (WD Green)
25A3 2TB - ST2000LM003 (Seagate/Samsung Spinpoint M9T)
作者: red_devil 時間: 2016-6-8 14:32
25H3 2TB - WD20NPVX (WD Green)
25A3 2TB - ST2000LM003 (Seagate/Samsung Spinpoint M9T)
pc1668 發表於 2016-6-8 12:55
Thx,

