回覆  PPLd


Hi, please clarify 2 points:

1) any photo about the card reader? you say you never us ...
Mr_devil 發表於 2016-9-22 09:35



    I have already made myself clear.
This post is about the scratch, not the repair work.
Why are you trying to involve another task into our discussion?
Can we focus on the major issue?

In case if you dont understand, let me simplify it again for you here.
I take a product for inspection and checking.
It is entirely my final decision to fix or not at whatever it would cost.
I can even throw it around at my home as I wish.

However, they added 2 scratches to my property during this process;
and I am telling a fact on a public forum that the company had admitted they had been negligent in the process, but refuse to take any responsibility or discuss with the consumer.
Do you still have difficulties in understanding?

TOP

This is not my intention.
But if they are willing to fix the exterior, I will accept that too ...
PPLd 發表於 2016-9-22 13:20


Do you still have valid warranty at that time ? Would you please cofirm the eligibility of the warranty is voided by Kingston after inspection ?

TOP

本帖最後由 Tenzin 於 2016-9-22 13:42 編輯
其實任何消費者為自己嘅權益去抗爭,最後得益嘅係一眾消費者而並非單純抗爭者本身,最起碼將來有類似嘅 case 代理都唔敢做得太樣衰。所以對於樓主我係支持嘅

OT,令我諗起 xda 之前一篇討論:
http://www.xda-developers.com/xd ... void-your-warranty/
我結論係,消費者俾人剝削慣,已經習以為常,亦係最可悲嘅地方
奶茶走甜 發表於 2016-9-21 14:47


呢樣並不是完全對的, 你要在維權前面加上「合理」兩個字
否則中國大媽因為飛機唔等佢而上唔到飛機, 因而在登機處的地上左滾滾右滾滾, 大叫大哭算唔算維權?
不合理的維權只會引發賣買相方互相的博奕, 最終結果就是可能以後上代理時, 代理會請專人用半個小時去檢驗商品的外型有沒有花痕, 甚至拍下各個角度的照片又或寫下要求保修產品的詳細描述來保障自己, 最終的所有成本包括時間都會是消費者找數
勞工維權不好嗎? 那爭取勞工每天上班8小時有7小時可以自由上網打機的權利不好嗎? 真的爭取到, 你以為得益的會是勞工嗎?
其實依家判斷樓主呢單case誰是誰非還是太早, 因為還有一些事情樓主都還沒有交代, 你既然開了人家的店舖名字來指責人, 那你亦同時亦有義務要受到網友的同樣質詢和交待

TOP

本帖最後由 PPLd 於 2016-9-22 13:42 編輯
最後, 想再次提醒你幾十蚊唔值搞咁多野. 唔係唔拎去保. 大家只係討論, 樓主係九月十五日既報警行為. 再者, 現時樓主報警原因同維修, 更換無乜任何關係啦.
556556bt 發表於 2016-9-22 12:40



    I had come across a court case for a $50 item.
The entire process took hundreds of thousands just for this.
Do you think it is worth?
It is hard to justify, pun intended.
You never know something until you do.

TOP

本帖最後由 556556bt 於 2016-9-22 14:10 編輯
I treat every item with fair attitude that an average customer can expect. That is the point.

Off ...
PPLd 發表於 2016-9-22 07:36



    I don't know how you define the fairness in your mind


Your fairness in mind might be drawing a straight line to all stuff. You recongize everything in fair same standard to all product you accquire whatever it is,  no matter how much you pay for it. You expect they would provide  same degree of service at the highest level.

However, the world is not operate in this way.

One thing to share, I had Thinkpad notebook sent to service in years ago and return me that some defective pixel on LCD, some weird sound from circuit board and bad sector of HDD. I keep complain even reported to consumer council and request for qualified warranty service.

I did what they required and they offer me requestd repair even the warranty was expired during the disputed period. They even offered me in door repair and delivery which not included in original warranty terms. Finally, they offered me one year extension of international warranty free of charge when the notebook didn't work overseas.

What I trying to say, the dealer provide me such extra service not because I have Ferrari or Benz, not because I bought the Thinkpad rather than IdeaPad. IBM/Lenovo offered me because they recongized my request is reasonable.

It's reasonable that my notebook still have valid warranty. The parts replaced didn't reach certain standard and it didn't work flawlessly and I tested and filed the case immediately. All we discussed is the functionality of the product and not twsited for external appearence.

Btw, what action I took and channel I complained to is at the right and accurate. I do right thing and do thing right.

TOP

I had come across a court case for a $50 item.
The entire process took hundreds of thousands  ...
PPLd 發表於 2016-9-22 13:39



    Whether worth or not is up to your standard. You can even file a case for 0 value.
However, the court's judgement is not based on how much effort you report. It's totally based on the evidence and what you request is reasonable.

Would your please telling us the whole story of this $50 case and the final result of court judgement. That should be very interesting.

TOP

本帖最後由 PPLd 於 2016-9-22 14:14 編輯
It's reasonable that my notebook still have valid warranty. The parts replaced didn't reach certain standard and it didn't work flawlessly and I tested and filed the case immediately. All we discussed is the functionality of the product and not twsited for external appearence.

556556bt 發表於 2016-9-22 13:54



    So you are suggesting that if your item is sent in for repair at dealer for a quotation,
too expensive I decided to leave,
and they can do whatever they like and scratch the external appearance at will?
And you call it fair because you only care reasonable function?
Great, I like your generosity and can I borrow things from you in future?

Of course functionality has a role, but there are more than functionality.
For instance, when handling a customer's item, I would handle it carefully.
If I make an item that is easy to scratch, then I should know (because I am the dealer) and take even more care.

TOP

So you are suggesting that if your item is sent in for repair at dealer for a quotation,
too  ...
PPLd 發表於 2016-9-22 14:10



    You still mention the scratch and do nothing to queries from others ?

Please be reminded the "scratch" you mentioned is still in suspicious status.
The eligibility of the warranty of the card reader is un-confirmed.

TOP

You still mention the scratch and do nothing to queries from others ?

Please be reminded the ...
556556bt 發表於 2016-9-22 14:15



    My entire post is about scratch and not relevant to other points in the queries.
I am now aware that you have special needs.

TOP

呢樣並不是完全對的, 你要在維權前面加上「合理」兩個字
否則中國大媽因為飛機唔等佢而上唔到飛機, 因而 ...
Tenzin 發表於 2016-9-22 13:38



    其實樓主, 不斷重複又重複幾條scratch. 不單幾條scratch 何時出現無人知曉. 保養是否一早失效亦不置可否. 對任何查問亦spin 去全不相關言論.

CHING 提出"合理" 一詞相當重要. 樓主出post 於此都係想得人認同. 但事件是合情合理至關重要. 樓主一路提出要求對方給予佢一D野. 似在維護權益, 但呢個權益同其付出是否合當和合理呢?
若然佢提出Kingston 判其保養失效, 還有合理既爭議性. 但呢點似乎樓主一早認同對方決定, 沒有異議.

TOP